This is being republished, I originally posted it on October 1, 2010.
Advice on how to save money is everywhere these days. Everyone has their tips & tricks and every media outlet is just filled with “experts” telling us how to save money. Every time I see a clip coming up on tv, I’m interested. I certainly consider myself bargain-savvy, but that doesn’t mean I can’t learn something new. Or in some cases it serves as a reminder to something that I meant to do but never got around to (like covering the hot water heater). And in some cases, the advice falls under the phrase of that bad 80s song “Things that make you go hmmmmm.” Today was that day. This morning on the Today show, they announced that “America’s Cheapest Family” was coming up with some advice. So I grabbed my coffee and stayed tuned.
The host introduced them and then said they had three many pieces of advice. Keep in mind that I had two little ones in the room with noisy toys, so I didn’t catch all of it.
The first piece of advice was that when cooking, to double recipes so that you have more and have to cook less. I’ve tried this and it didn’t work for us. First, you don’t save any money on shopping, as you’re still purchasing the same ingredients, just more of them. And for us, I found we had MUCH more waste. For example, I would prepare (usually on a Sunday) a double batch of lasagne, chili or something like that. That would be our Sunday dinner. We’d take it for lunch on Monday, and then have it again Monday night for dinner. I will say that I certainly concede it is much easier to just reheat something on a Monday night instead of cooking. But that’s a time saving measure, not money saving. Tuesday, I’d take it for lunch again, and at this point, hubby would refuse to eat it again for dinner. I would continue to dutifully eat said reheated meal until I couldn’t take it anymore, and usually end up tossing about a third to one quarter of the original batch.
If I prepare just a regular sized batch, we either have no leftovers or we have one or two servings of leftovers which get eaten the next day. No waste. Maybe if you have a larger family or if it’s a dish that you can freeze right away, it works. I have found though, that freezing the already prepared food, sometimes freezing it does funky things to the texture and consistency. And I have a vacuum sealer, still doesn’t work out.
The second bit was something about only grocery shopping once a month. I can’t get into this idea. Almost all grocery stores change their sales weekly, what might be free or almost free one week will be full price the next. A monthly budget is a monthly budget–whether or not you split it up into four weeks. Make a budget and stick to it. Unless you live in extremely rural areas, the gas savings are minimal.
Then the daughters piped in that when they get home from the grocery store, that they (the kids) help put away the groceries. And they help with meal preparation too. Nice gesture, but I fail to see how that plays any role in saving money. A viewer called in and asked “How do you keep produce for a month?” Great question! I like to feed my family healthy stuff. The mom said that produce does in fact keep for a month. Yeah, I’m calling bs on that one. It does not. I challenge her to find me any baby greens or spinach that will last a month.
I was starting to lose interest at this point, and another viewer called in. She said she liked to shop with coupons and wanted to know how she could get more. The answer they gave–have a coupon swap in your neighborhood. Ok, not terrible advice, but….really? That’s all you got? How about coupons.com, smartsource.com, redplum.com, store websites, manufacturers’ websites, e-coupons, store flyers and circulars….I could go on. There are plenty of places to get more coupons without bugging my neighbors. I know of some moms who do this and it works great if you have a local network of couponers. But if you don’t, then what?
I don’t know how “America’s Cheapest Family” earned that honor. I know of a mom that can feed a family of five (healthy stuff too!) on $800 a year. I may just nominate her for the show.
So sorry Today show, imo you failed this time. Give me some news I can use!
Updated: Here is a post I did recently on 30 ways to trim your grocery budget. I am getting back on the budget bandwagon and seeing real savings again! Click the banner to view it.